In this paper your task is to summarize the argumentation in each of two articles and then provide an assessment (your own argument) as to which article does a better job of making and supporting its case.

In this paper your task is to summarize the argumentation in each of two articles and then provide an assessment (your own argument) as to which article does a better job of making and supporting its case. For the latter, you must provide at lest two supporting arguments of your own to explain why you think that one article is stronger than the other.
Properly cited using footnotes and a bibliography using Chicago style
Both sources are in the jpg files along with the outline for each part of the essay