There are two primary components of your article critique: textual analysis and

There are two primary components of your article critique: textual analysis and evaluation. An excellent critique will consider the questions/concepts detailed below.
Analysis
These are the questions you need to be asking and taking note of while reading the article.
What is the author’s thesis? You have to identify their thesis directly.
What arguments does the author use in support of their thesis? You need to identify all parts of the argument.
What evidence does the author present in support of the argument?
Be specific about the types of secondary source evidence: articles, books, or other academic secondary sources.
Be specific about the types of primary source evidence: letters, journals, newspaper reports, government documents from the period, etc.
Then analyze the effectiveness of those sources in supporting the author’s argument.
Evaluation
You will offer your appraisal of the author’s work based upon the following points.
Does the author offer an argumentative thesis that is related to the assigned prompt? You may wish to evaluate the degree to which the author’s submission accomplishes this goal.
Does the author offer a lucid, coherent argument in support of the thesis? You may wish to evaluate the degree to which the author’s submission accomplishes this goal.
Are the author’s facts accurate? Are there significant portions of this story that the author failed to address?
Is the evidence presented in support of the argument reliable? Does it demonstrate the author’s consideration of varying interpretations of the event discussed?
Does the text present and refute opposing points of view?
What questions or observations does this article suggest? Does it point to areas for further study?
I am posting an example of how to do the assignment so you can do mines similar. I’m also going to post what their assignment